Ubuntu Future Interface: Gnome-Shell vs. Unity!

Printer-friendly version

 

Gnome Shell

 

Since its first release in 2004, Ubuntu has always adopted the idea of “Linux for human beings”. Ubuntu was the first Linux distribution to introduce “user experince” to the Linux arena. However, other open-source projects never feared engaging this competition! Ubuntu and the Gnome Desktop Environment have always formed Ubuntu's unique brown appearance. However, things are changing and the completion is getting more intense, Ubuntu has decided to ship with Unity as its default interface since ubuntu 10.04, and the Gnome project has released Gnome 3 with its totally new brand, Gnome-shell. In the days of Ubuntu 10.04 it was impossible to have both Gnome shells, which depend on Gnome 3, along with Unity, which depended on Gnome 2 then. However, as Ubuntu 10.10 was released, we are now able to easily choose and install either one or both. so, let’s dive into the comparison between them!

 

1- Doc on the sidebar

both interfaces have a Doc on the sidebar which is pretty much similar, except the fact that the sidebar of unity does resize icons and allows you to scroll to see extra icons, and it is generally more interactive and allows the applications to use docs to  give a  feedback to the user (think, copy progress, or timer programs...)

2- Search on Super (windows) key press and a new menu system

When you click theWindows” key known as “Super” in the Linux world! you can just start typing to search for Files, Music or applications, but in Gnome-Shell, if your search term doesn’t meet any of the files or applications you will get the ability to search Google or Wikipedia

 

3- Daemons Area, and notifications

 

While Unity still supports the default notifications popup of Gnome, one of its biggest pitfalls is that it changes the daemons area (the area at which programs add icons on the top bar) which deprived many users of their preferred applications Sad, However, Gnome-Shell has developed an amazing bottom-sliding notification system that notifies you about everything on your system from applications that have already loaded and partitions mounted to normal chat or RSS notifications, while still being compatible with the old daemons!
 

4- The global menu bar of Unity

Ubuntu Unity is moving “more mac-like” as we go, but I can’t deny that I like that tiny, well-organized, global menu bar... in fact this is one of the things you will really miss in Gnome-Shell, but we hope it will come to Gnome-shell at some future release!

5- Window Switching

 

 

 

 

Unity has just got a new update for its window switcher (alt + Tab) it is more usable than that of Gnome-Shell because it is more intuitive when you have more than a window of the same program, they are grouped together and it is just enough to wait a second to select between windows of the same program.... However, Gnome-Shell has a very nice feature when it comes to window selecting, when you click “super” you can easily see all your open windows, select between them with arrows, close them or organize them between different desktops by a simple drag and drop!

 

These have been the most noteworthy features for me, but I would definitely like to hear about your comparisons in the comments!

As a final remark, I would say that both Unity and Gnome-Shell are working very hard to be more usable and elegant. However, I see that both are not stable enough, and contain some quirky bugs so far! But this competition is very useful for the good of the open source community!


Author Info


mustafadagher's picture
Web Developer @ Magnlology.net, Web Developer @ SIFE CairoUniversity. A student in the faculty of Engineering, Cairo university. crazy about Computer gaming, programming, web developing. I have lots of hobbies , interests and friends as well. I'm interested in technology, Writing Poems, music, football, making friends and knowing new people. I wanna be a good & beloved person.

Your rating: None Average: 4.3 (3 votes)

Comments

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.

Random Articles

  It is so obvious from the title that Max Payne is a series. The first game of it was released in 2001 and it was about a detective who is pursuing those who murdered his wife and child to get revenge. While the second one, dubbed Max Payne 2: The Fall of Max Payne, is about Max Payne, the protagonist, who is about to face the police because... Sarah M. Qassem Viewed 191 times
    While I was shopping for books, a book named "55 love Stories" grabbed my attention. What was amazing is that I didn't expect Doctor Mustafa Mahmoud to write a book about love. I bought it and I was sure that what is inside the book would be different form the title, but I was wrong. It is a narrating 55 sad love stories that was... Amany Talaat Shehata Viewed 140 times
         Imagine that you are passing by a huge building, don't know what is inside, full of curiosity to know but, no one is near to ask. What a lost of time? In the near future and by using the future internet search: Mobile version, you don't need to ask anyone about anything because you will have the answers of... Amany Talaat Shehata Viewed 151 times
  Our generation has witnessed the most colorful collection of world events, including two world wars, a nuclear disaster, revolutions, nations collapsing, nations prospering, regimes toppled, leaders abandoning their tyranny, mass murders, famines, and the list goes on. It has become a normal characteristic in our everyday life to... Anonymous Viewed 219 times